Analysing Top Tier Offlaners - Part 1
Last week concluded our Support series, where we have discussed the relevance of top pick supports in public matchmaking. Today we are starting a new series, dedicated to the offlane heroes.
As usual, our focus will not be primarily on the ways to play the hero, but rather an overall analysis of why and when it is a good game to pick a certain offlaner. Today we will have a look at three most popular offlane heroes in the current meta: 
Batrider, 
Bristleback and 
Clockwerk.
Batrider
Ever since the release of the hero in Captains Mode he has been a top pick priority, despite constant nerfs.
Originally, he was played in a Mid position with a relative success, but the meta shifts as well as a devastating nerf to his basic Attack damage resulted in a switch to an offlane role he is currently played in.
So why is the hero so persistent in Professional matches?
There are a lot of reasons for that, but the most important one is that you can not quantify utility effects - it is easy to nerf/buff things like Damage on a spell, Basic Attack Time or even Vision to balance a hero, but the 
Flaming Lasso is strong by design. It is the only spell in game which can reliably change the position of an enemy hero. All while disabling him AND punishing the other heroes in the enemy team in case they want to pursuit you to initiate a fight or save the teammate. Henceforth, it is impossible to tweak some numbers to get the hero weaker at what he does best - you either redesign his ultimate or keep him in the game intact, to forever remain the first pick/ban material for and against the teams who can utilise his strength.
He is also among the offlane heroes, which are relatively hard to shut down - the ability to flash-farm jungle stacks means that he can never be truly left penniless and the relatively low cost of reaching extremely high effectiveness means that he is almost never a bad pick. 
Tranquil Boots + 
Blink Dagger + 
Force Staff sums up to 5500 gold and Force Staff, while being a core item, is still not necessary in the early game to secure most kills.
His offlane presence in the trilane vs Batrider situation is pretty low. He can occasionally suicide to get an early kill/first blood, but his escape in the form of 
Firefly does not provide the necessary amount of safety to reliably get gold in the lane. At the same time, especially as the Radiant offlaner, you can always stack/farm the Large neutrals which are extremely close to lane and can be stacked from the River with the vision provided by either an 
Observer Ward or 
Sticky Napalm.
And here comes the main question of this Blog post: when do you pick Batrider? An easy answer would be - "always", when you need an offlaner. If you can play him properly and can understand the threat of the enemy trilane and weight your options as to whether to already go jungle or try to soak XP/Gold in lane - you can win a lot of teamfights before they even start.
Nuances include:
the trust you put in your team's supports to actively stack the jungle for you.
the ability of your team to actually get a kill on a disabled target before the enemy can react.
presence of
Vengeful Spirit, 
Shadow Demon, [missing hero: outworld-devourer], 
Naga Siren, 
Legion Commander, 
Abaddon on the enemy team.the probability of the enemy getting multiple or single
Linken's Sphere and the additional utility/synergy they get from it.
Additionally, the hero really asks for extra vision, either in the form of aggressive Wards, [missing skill: beastmaster-call-of-the-wild-hawk-5169] or other summons, since despite having flying vision during Firefly, it is still 1200/800 and can prevent Batrider from seeing potential openings for a move.
Bristleback
To be perfectly fair, Bristleback is probably not the second most popular offlaner in the game, since a lot of picks he got was to fill the safelane solo farming poistion, rather than the offlane one. That said he is still quite popular in the current professional meta to justify the presence in this blog post.
When discussing supports in the previous blog posts, we have touched on the idea that the current meta favours single target burst damage to snowball the fight with a 1 hero advantage in most engagements. It also introduced a lot of burst physical DPS heroes, which tend to quickly come "online" with cheap, high "return-on-investment" items, but do not necessarily fall off later in the game (e.g. 
Brewmaster vs 
Troll Warlord). So where exactly does Bristleback fit into this picture?
As it turns out, pretty much everywhere. Very much like 
Juggernaut and Troll Warlord, he can come online extremely fast. In most cases he only needs 
Power Treads + around ~2000 (can be a choice between several DPS or survivability items) gold to be already considered a threat, with great innate tankiness, punishing AoE damage and strong autoattacks. And what makes it all come together is the fact that at this particular moment in game, given the same or even inferior gold investment, Bristleback will be able to achieve comparable damage output capabilities of other popular autoattackers/cores, while directly countering them by simply not dying.
He can not be ignored and he is very hard to kill - properties, which made 
Dragon Knight popular for some period. But while DK needs his levels to get to a point where ignoring him can cost you a teamfight, Bristleback is happy to facerush even at level 7-10, time where teams are most vulnerable to the potentially snowballing Juggernaut and Troll Warlord.
The pick around Bristleback should complement this early-game strength to allow for a mild "rush" type of game plan - if he is not snowballed, he will gradually fall off and become less relevant, as the enemy gets their levels/items. He also falls short when it comes to dealing with heroes that have a lot of mobility (e.g. 
Storm Spirit) or can safely autoattack you from a distance without the means for you of closing the gap quickly and reliably (e.g. 
Medusa and 
Sniper). Investing in a Blink Dagger is not an option.
He can also be bursted quickly if played wrong - you want to show your back to the enemy hero with the highest potential DPS when you expect a nuke/autoattack and sometimes it is better to run ahead and focus other heroes, rather than trying to manfight an enemy core. With that in mind, he does not necessarily deal well with heroes which have long duration hard disables, which prevent you from turning (e.g. 
Lion, 
Axe), but excels at dealing with heroes which have a lot of damage at the cost of mobility/utility (e.g. 
Skywrath Mage, 
Visage, 
Zeus, 
Crystal Maiden).
Your general battle plan is to run into the enemy supports, ignoring their carry and letting your team deal with him at a number advantage, while you scare away the rest of the enemy team. Chances are - you will not only disable blinks of the enemy counter-initiators, but will survive the preferable to you 1vs2-4 engagement, while your team focuses the enemy carry, who tries to either protect his teammates chasing after you, or fights the rest of your team. Unlike you, it will be hard for him to survive an engagement under a number disadvantage in the earlier stages of the game.
Clockwerk
The story of Clockwerk in competitive scene is somewhat interesting - he was always an option, but somehow never a priority. However, with the rise of both melee and ranged heroes, which want to just stand and autoattack, he finally got his chance at a spotlight.
Clockwerk is quite versatile when it comes to his build. Depending on the situation, he can rush either a Force Staff or 
Blade Mail. First one is amazing at disabling enemy melee carries for prolonged amounts of time by cogging them, force-staffing out and ignoring or killing from range. The latter is a generally good item if you intend to tank the damage and is better if you go in deep into the enemy team to deal with the annoying support or ranged carry. Ideally you should have both in most cases, but with their price being roughly the same, the initial choice is very important.
His damage output with 
Battery Assault got a rather strong early-game buff, totalling 320 damage and annoying microstuns at level 1. At level 4 it has the potential to deal 1280 damage to a single target over 10.5s and it is not surprising to see many professional players max the skill first, as opposed to previously popular 
Rocket Flare focus.
Rocket Flare, even at level 1 is an amazing tool for scouting and getting the enemy Blink Daggers on cooldown against counter-initiation. Its nuke potential is really low, but it can still be used to either harass/last hit in lane or outpush other lanes.
While Clockwerk is good against pretty much any team which has a non-mobile core (e.g. not Storm Spirit, 
Morphling etc.), he truly shines as a hero with a set-up for a big skillshot (e.g. 
Kunkka, Skywrath Mage, 
Lina). Additionally, he can literally create a wall between the enemy and his glass cannon ranged teammates, something that will come in handy in a lot of situations.
With all that said, there are still plenty of downsides on the hero. Out of all three heroes mentioned today, he probably suffers the most if facing a trilane. He has no option to jungle and his only escape ability - 
Power Cogs is not exactly the most reliable escape tool. He can occasionally last hit with Rocket Flare, but most supports can easily zone him out of the XP range alone. He is easily ganked and needs extra caution during the laning stage, which can lead to him becoming quite irrelevant without ever becoming relevant (e.g. early Force Staff on supports). On top of that, he also tampers with the ability of your melee teammates to deal damage.
With all this information in mind, answering the question of when to pick him becomes quite hard. In many cases Clockwerk should not be first-picked and is generally best when he is a surprise to the enemy and it is too late to get more than one hero to play around his strengths. So if you happen to last pick, go through the list of the ideas listed here and if no or little red flags pop up into mind, he can be a great addition to the team in the right hands.
Closing Comments
This concludes our analysis of the Top 3 most popular offlaners in the game. In most cases, selecting an offlane hero will be harder than selecting a support, since there are more things to factor in. That said, the pool of heroes in Dota 2 is still big enough to find just the right thing.
Next week we will have a look at another trinity of heroes: 
Broodmother, 
Phoenix and 
Tidehunter, so stay tuned. Have a nice week!
I can't play clock worth shit. I'm bad and I feel bad.
Clock is hard.
Clockwerk is a pretty fun hero to play (especially if you can get the farm for a force/aghs/etc). I enjoy playing him mid, usually against heroes where if he can catch up to (with cogs) they can't escape/are dead that rely too much on kiting or space such as zeus, sniper, shadow fiend
(Since everyone is commenting on him) Clock is great!! Favourite hero almost since the start. High early damage, awesome skill-shot, global scouting and farming tool, fight-deciding blockade of electrical cogs! What's not to love about that. Such a make or brake hero with many build and item possibilities. Not a good meta for him with Juggernaut, Slark and Troll being so far up the pick-list in pubs these days, but he will come back! Btw, for those who hasn't realized it yet: Phase Boots are (generally) the best boots.
Clock = Top 3 most fun heroes in the game
Really loving these analysis posts; a lot of discussion comes up.
Batrider always a strong hero. I feel he's among the few heroes that are truly completely balanced (or at least, as closed go balance as you can get)
Clock getting back into the game is also really nice to see. Not one of the easier heroes to play and very dynamic in games. Provides a large amount of utility in a similar manner as batrider.
Bristle is an odd on out among the three here. Haven't been seeing him as much in the offlaner as we used to which is perfectly understandable considering how fast he can come online in a safe lane. Also among he few heroes who can stand up to the shit storm that is troll warlord, Jugg, sniper. At the same time, he doesn't seem to be that op as his stat growths aren't out of the world crazy.
Can't wait for the post on Phoenix, Tide and Broodmama. All three heroes I like to play in offline myself.
Give my boy Undying some love. He's a fun offlaner to play as too!
Clockwork is a really strong offlane vs melee heroes because of cogs intense mana removal, so you just run up to the creepwave and cog and bounce anyone farming away, that way they have less kill potential and you can last hit/suck XP a little safer.
Another thing you can you on the dire side is cog in a very specific place (I don't remember exactly where, its a pro strat) so that some creeps run into the trees and get stuck, pulling your wave back to the tower and denying those creeps to their safelane.
interesting... Can't wait to see another Analysis in depth.. good work.
clock's biggest weakness is he has to spend a lot of mana to flash farm and even then it's not very fast. which means you both eat runes and fall off late game. still my most played and fave hero, but i've been playing a lot more axe/pudge offlane lately.
Looking forward for timber, imo the best off hero ^^
Pudge, Mirana, Timber, u need to add them into next part, btw, im clock player, and that was really strong hero:/
i dont think that potm is a strong offlaner in this meta :/
i can't batrider -_
dafuq
always lose with that flying badass
Clock is love
Clock is life
I'm just wondering are there any good alternatives on Vanguard/CG on Bristle, I was thinking about Atos, it can work as a cheap version of Skadi.
What do you guys think?
It all depends on the enemy team nrzl. If they're heavy magic dmg, pipe would most likely be better to go than vanguard. Or if they have a strong right clicker such as PA, then a Halberd would be a good first item. Atos wouldn't be a bad first item if your teams draft allows you to be super greedy in the first 15-20 minutes, however survivability and regen is typically the best way to go to get those quill stacks.
Clock is not suffering from trilane ....
He just need to cog creep to get the xp under his tower, which is all he need to start a game.
@nrzl, Atos is a fine item, but mostly heroes that really benefit from it should get it (Sky, Krob, Silencer, Enchantress). 2 Vit Boosters gives only additional raw hp, no regen. and +10 int from staff is kinda dumb for his' skills are cheap spammables. If you are gonna build something with staff of wizardry, it should be Force Staff, helps him really well. Offensive & Defensive type of Bristle. I DEFINITELY NOT RECCOMEND RoA on BB.
Anyways, waiting for that Tidehunter, he's one of my best heroes as a Role 4 & 5 Support.
clock is the easiest thing to play after BA buff
Cant wait for phoenix,my favourite and imo one of the best offlane heroes <3
Offlane player myself, hugely enjoyed this article and I'm pretty sure I will enjoy the rest of the series too.
Download some Clockwerk plays from me. 61% winrate. I really enjoy to play this fantastic dynamic hero. He forms the battleground by splitting the enemys with cogs in two groups for example. So he shines to remain Mapcontrol constantly.
I prefer Bat mid as i can pick up a really early Blink and Tranquils and head to the lanes to gank as soon as i hit lvl 6. He such a powerful laner and ganker.
Looking forward to the Phoenix and Earth spirit episodes - I believe these to be the two best offlaners overall (but not in every situation!)
^ I thought this series analyzed some of the uses in the competitive scene. Earth Spirit is banned in captains mode and therefore not used in pro games, so what is there to analyze?
I wonder if they will touch on some of the non-traditional offlaners that do well in the offlane, mainly thinking of Beastmaster, Lich, and ET.
NICE THEME
I'd like to see what people's opinions are on the new heroes being run on offlane. Namely Magnus and Morphling. They are not quite common, yet have been done enough times recently that people are actually considering it.
Also, will they ever cover some other potential offlaners like QoP, Puck, and not to mention some other heroes who have been played a lot in the offlane and are known in the position like Void, Weaver, Centaur Warrunner, Spirit Breaker, Undying, and Zues even. Some may not be used as much, but some are. Axe even. Or did they just not mention them, and only mention the next 3? I hope they atleast follow up with the Offlane Axe, Spirit Breaker, and Centaur.
It was said that clock's only escape is his cogs- this is true in most cases- but in an emergency (Or with Aghanim's) you can quite easily hookshot neutrals or perhaps a team mate to prevent your immanent death.
Magnus was a common off laner back in the old days. Farm with wave, escape with skwer. Get dagger and force team fight. Nothing much to analyse.
I am interested in spirit breaker and morphing though. They both need level. But they are both easily zone out. Good warding and tp by opponents mean that it is hard for u to gank mid pre 6 unless you are counter ganking or they had over commit.
Clockwerk is tough because of his mana requirements I find. Obviously with a bottle it helps, but that assumes you have full rune control for it to be effective. In addition to that, being in the enemy's safe lane, you end up taking a lot of harassment (if the opponent support knows anything), so its always situational as to what to get first, whether it be phase boots or a secret-shop ring of health, and then from there on to blade mail. I suck bad with clock so I never play him. Always nice having a guy on the team who can play him though.
puck fast
I love clockwerk! Don't play him often but my most recent game was 23-0-12. That was with an omniknight on my team though, which makes a great combo as his heal makes clockwerk more likely to survive if he cogs someone, and also deals a decent 300 pure damage nuke. All in all, they work very well together.
Well even if you use this offlaners you can't do shit coz two enemy supports will harass you so badly.
"Flaming Lasso is strong by design. It is the only spell in game which can reliably change the position of an enemy hero. "
Someone forgot about Nether Swap.
well done , keep it up , but i need more detail analysis about it
like BB quil spray 1 stack 80 damage, 2nd 116 damage, 3rd 152 damage, 4th 188 damage etc
and its combo very well with VS or other minus armor , such as SF
i think more deep detail is more interesting
Most difficult part in playing Clock is positioning, and that's where I usually fail. i also like Timbersaw who has same difficulty